Will No Tax on Tips Pass?

No Tax on Tips

Since the campaign, President Trump has help firm in his intention to remove federal taxes on tips for service workers.

While this may sound like a generous offer aimed at supporting the hardworking individuals in the hospitality and service sectors, the reality is more complex.

Let’s dissect this proposal, looking at its potential benefits, drawbacks, and broader implications.

And if you want to stay up-to-date on all 2025 tax updates, check out our tracker.

What’s the Proposal?

Trump declared that, if re-elected, one of his first actions would be to ensure that tips earned by service workers are exempt from federal taxes.

This plan, according to Trump, is designed to offer financial relief to employees who rely heavily on tips, such as waiters, bartenders, and hotel staff.

Who Stands to Benefit?

Initially, it seems like a win for all service workers. However, the real beneficiaries of this policy would be a relatively small group.

High-end restaurant waitstaff, for instance, who earn substantial tips, would see the most significant financial benefit.

According to the Labor Department, the top 10% of waitstaff earn over $60,000 annually, with a significant portion coming from tips. These individuals would enjoy a noticeable increase in take-home pay if their tips were tax-free.

The Reality for Most Tipped Workers

Despite the potential upsides, many tipped workers might find little to no benefit from Trump’s proposal.

The federal minimum wage for tipped workers stands at $2.13 per hour, with their total earnings (including tips) required to meet or exceed the federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour. In states like Oklahoma, where the tipped minimum wage is also $2.13, many workers earn so little that they already pay minimal or no federal income tax.

Consider this: half of the waitstaff in the U.S. make $32,000 or less annually. A single worker earning this amount would owe around $1,900 in federal income tax, which could be further reduced or eliminated through credits such as the Child Tax Credit or the Earned Income Tax Credit. Consequently, many of these workers already face a low tax burden, diminishing the impact of Trump’s proposed tax exemption on tips.

Will No Tax on Tips Pass?

The House has advanced a GOP budget resolution that sets the stage for extending Trump’s 2017 tax cuts and implementing new cuts totaling $4.5 trillion over the next decade. This move could support Trump’s pledge to eliminate taxes on tips, though it’s uncertain if lawmakers will have enough budget flexibility to implement it.

Trump first proposed the “no tax on tips” policy in Nevada, where tipped workers are prevalent, and reaffirmed his commitment in January. The plan could involve exempting tips from federal income taxes, payroll taxes, or both, potentially with industry-specific limits.

Several bills have been introduced to support this initiative, including:

• The No Tax on Tips Act, which would allow qualifying workers to exempt up to $25,000 in tips from federal income tax.
• The Tipped Income Protection and Support (TIPS) Act, which would eliminate the $2.13 hourly minimum wage for tipped workers and end income tax on tips.
• The Tip Tax Termination Act, which would exempt certain tips from income taxes for five years.

Potential Pitfalls and Unintended Consequences

While the plan has bipartisan support, critics warn it could worsen tipping fatigue and increase the federal deficit, potentially reducing revenue by over $100 billion in a decade.

Additionally, only a small portion of low-income workers would benefit, as many already pay little or no federal income tax.

A Historical Perspective

It’s worth noting that Trump’s proposal isn’t entirely new. Former Rep. Ron Paul suggested a similar idea in 2012.

He argued that tipped workers were overtaxed and pledged to work towards abolishing all taxes on tips. Despite the appeal of such a proposal, it never gained traction, highlighting the complexities and potential inequities involved in exempting tips from taxation.

Final Thoughts

Trump’s proposal to remove federal taxes on tips is certainly attention-grabbing and could offer tangible benefits to a select group of high-earning service workers. However, for the majority of tipped employees, especially those earning lower wages, the impact would likely be minimal.

Moreover, it appears this policy could hinder efforts to raise the minimum wage and create new challenges in maintaining tax equity and efficient tax administration.

As a tax professional, it’s essential to consider both the short-term gains and the long-term consequences of such policies.

While Trump’s plan aims to support service workers, it’s crucial to scrutinize who truly benefits and whether the policy achieves its intended goals without creating new issues for the broader workforce.

Stay up-to-date with our live tracker.