Selling Properties and Assets at a Loss

Look, no one likes selling investments for a loss, but that is just the kind of market we are currently living in. Whether you’re a seasoned real estate investor or a small business owner, knowing how to navigate these scenarios can make a significant difference in your financial outcomes. And also, when I say property, you can substitute asset for the most part.

Property Losses and The Tax Implications

When you sell a property (or any kind of asset) at a loss, the tax code provides specific treatments that can be beneficial. For instance, if you purchased a property in 2022 in Savannah, Georgia, and are now selling it for less than the purchase price, this loss is classified as a 1231 tax loss. I’ve seen this play out for clients, and then they receive a nice tax surprise even though they lost on their asset or investment.

Section § 1231 Gains and Losses

Section § 1231 of the Internal Revenue Code deals with the sale or exchange of business assets or capital assets that are used in connection with a ToB or a transaction entered into for profit. Or property that is eligible for depreciation qualifies as ‘being used in a trade or business’ as well (Inventory does not qualify here).

Real estate dealers or flippers rarely get the opportunity to utilize § 1231 treatment. Basically, if the property is used in your business, or you’re working in it for a profit endeavor, then you can be subject to § 1231 rates.

Whether you have a gain or a loss, the treatment under § 1231 is rather favorable.

• Section § 1231 Gains: If you sell business property at a gain, it is treated as a long-term capital gain, which is taxed at a maximum rate of 20%. However, depreciation recapture rules may apply, which could increase your tax liability. (And more times will convert the capital gain treatment to be ordinary treatment, especially if a cost segregation study had been performed.
• Section § 1231 Losses: If you sell business property at a loss, the loss is treated as an ordinary loss. This is a significant advantage because ordinary losses can offset other types of income, such as W-2 income or income from other businesses.

The Advantage of Ordinary Losses

The ability to treat a property loss as an ordinary loss rather than a capital loss is a key benefit. Capital losses are capped at $3,000 per year for offsetting ordinary income, unless you have other capital gains to offset. This limitation can be restrictive, especially if you have substantial losses. But ordinary losses are not subject to the same limitations.

This means that if you sell a property at a loss, you can potentially offset a significant portion of your other income, reducing your overall tax liability, and you’ll get to use your passive losses (if you have any) from the property against other types of income as well.

Essentially, if you sold a property, you could then double-stack the actual loss with your unused losses over time. I see this happen a lot with long-term rental owners.

Recouping Your Losses

While selling a property at a loss is never ideal, the tax code provides a silver lining. Depending on your tax rate, you could recoup up to 30% of your loss through tax savings.

1. An easy way to think about it is, for every dollar of loss, you could save up to 30 cents in taxes (depending on your tax bracket). This means that even if you don’t recoup the cash from the sale, you can still benefit from the tax savings.
2. Suspended Losses: If you’ve accumulated suspended passive losses over the years, selling the property at a loss can release these losses. You can then use them to offset other types of income, providing additional tax relief.
3. Also, if you sell at a loss, then you’ll never have to deal with depreciation recapture either. Normally, when a cost segregation study is formed, you’ll now be subject to depreciation recapture. But now, since you’re selling at a loss, you won’t have to deal with recapture (though you might have lost on your investment).

Reinvesting in Better Opportunities

Selling a property at a loss can free up capital that you can reinvest in more profitable ventures. For example, you could use the proceeds from the sale to purchase a property in a more promising market or to diversify your investment portfolio. The tax savings from the loss can also provide additional funds to reinvest.

Timing Your Sale

The timing of your property sale can have a significant impact on your tax liability. If you anticipate a loss, consider selling the property in a year when you have other income that can be offset by the loss. This can maximize your tax savings and improve your overall financial position.

One Caveat

There is a ‘netting’ process with § 1231 gains and losses. Essentially, in a 5-year window, if you have taken large § 1231 losses, but then have a matching amount of § 1231 gain, then you’ll be forced to ‘recapture’ the § 1231 by flipping this gain to be taxed at ordinary income rates. To be strategic, recognizing § 1231 gains before losses is more desirable, as this helps avoid that recapture procedure.

Conclusion: Turning a Loss into an Opportunity

Now, mind you, this does not work for capital assets or inventory (again), so real estate dealers and flippers rarely get to use it.

While selling a property at a loss is never the desired outcome, understanding the tax implications can help you turn a challenging situation into a strategic advantage.
By qualifying the loss as an ordinary loss, you can offset other types of income and potentially recoup a significant portion of your loss through tax savings. Additionally, the release of suspended passive losses can provide further tax relief.

For real estate investors and SMB owners, these tax benefits can be a powerful tool in managing your financial portfolio. By strategically timing your sale and reinvesting in better opportunities, you can turn a property loss into a stepping stone for future success.

If you have any questions or need assistance with navigating property loss and its tax implications, don’t hesitate to reach out. We’re here to help you make the most of your investments and achieve your financial goals.

Ready to partner with a team that knows exactly what they’re doing? Book a discovery call today.